https://bringatrailer.com/cadillac/ct5-ct5-v/ · 83 completed auctions ·
40 read in depth · compiled · 2 versions on file
The figures below were computed by an earlier build of the
analysis and do not carry
later corrections to it. Refreshing this case file recomputes them from the same cars.
A 668-hp manual super-sedan that has shed roughly 30% of its 2022-23 auction value — the market now pays for spec sheets (CF1/CF2, carbon-ceramics, three pedals, delivery miles), not for badges or MSRP.
$127,305 ·
$81,500 ·
$88,500 ·
$93,500 ·
$79,000 ·
$87,000 ·
Median sold
$96,639
58 sales
Typical range
$87,375–$105,000
middle 50%
Last 12 months
$90,000
-6.9% year over year
Sell-through
70%
25 reserve not met
All-time high
$136,500
The market
Across all 83 completed BaT auctions the sold median is $96,639 (mean $97,959, 25th pct $87,375, 75th pct $105,000, full range $77,000–$136,500), but that headline number is a historical artefact. The year-by-year medians tell the real story: $125,068 in 2022 (n=4), $108,500 in 2023 (n=8), $94,000 in 2024 (n=21), $93,000 in 2025 (n=17), $87,750 in 2026 (n=8). Trailing-twelve-months median is $90,000 against $96,639 the year before, -6.9%. The scarcity premium of the launch years is gone; what remains is a slow grind down as more cars come to market and buyers absorb the fact that Cadillac kept building them through 2026.
Sell-through is 69.9% (58 sold of 83), and the 25 no-sales cluster tightly around one cause: sellers anchoring on MSRP or on build cost. 2026 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed cars failed three times in the deep-analysed set — $135,000 against a $144,390 sticker, $117,000 against $139,500, and $95,000 against $107,960 — with badcad writing on the second of those, "wow no bids after 7/25/26. Very unusual. Given the CF1/2 and upgraded interior which is very hard to get this should have sold very close to MSRP." It did not. Meanwhile 2022–24 cars with real miles keep trading: 23k-Mile 2022 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed at $80,501, 2024 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed (15,000 miles, CF1, carbon-ceramics) at $86,000, and the 9,600-mile 2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed out of Denver at $80,500. That $80–88k band is the current floor for a driven manual car.
One caution on the transmission statistics: the computed medians are Manual $91,000 (n=26) versus Automatic $89,500 (n=6). That is a $1,500 gap on a six-car automatic sample — statistically nothing. The qualitative record is far more emphatic than the arithmetic: automatics that stumbled include 1,200-Mile 2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing (RNM at $76,500) and 46-Mile 2025 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing Le Monstre Edition (RNM at $134,000), while the automatics that did sell were either heavily optioned anniversary cars or cheap. On colour, only two have five or more cars: Black Raven $96,500 (n=5) and Summit White $89,500 (n=5) — suggestive, not conclusive.
Every completed auction. Filled = sold, hollow = reserve not met. Line = median sold price per year.Median sold price per year; the vertical line spans that year’s low to high.
What moves the price
Delivery-to-sub-1,000 miles premium +25-35% over a 10k-mile car
Six-speed manual premium real but small in the data — medians say +$1,500 ($91,000 n=26 vs $89,500 n=6); the qualitative record implies more like +5-10%
The computed transmission medians barely separate, and the automatic sample is only six cars. What the threads show is failure risk concentrated in automatics: 1,200-Mile 2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing (base automatic) RNM at $76,500 despite 1,200 miles, and 46-Mile 2025 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing Le Monstre Edition RNM at $134,000 with manofmanuals noting "the 26 manual 5BWs F1 edition has the best chance of being collectable." On 29-Mile 2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 120th Anniversary Edition 6-Speed ($111,000), Gigi2020 supplied the direct comp — an automatic 120th with 3,600 miles at $96,500. Manual cars also lack AFM cylinder deactivation and stop/start, which commenter Zenk flagged as a durability plus.
Carbon-ceramic brakes (CCB) / Precision Package premium +$5-10k at best — well under the ~$9-12k option cost
AZSkye, an owner, was blunt on 2026 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed: "IMO, the Precision Package won't be worth as much as the 6 speed in the future. The nice part about the PP is you get the ceramic brakes which will last up to 100K miles unless you track it." That car, with $18k of Precision Package plus CF1/CF2, still stopped at $117,000. On 2024 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed (15,000 miles, CF1 + CCB) badcad predicted "I'm thinking 110k"; it sold for $86,000. Ceramics help, but nowhere near cost.
Full-body vinyl wrap concealing factory paint discount enough to kill the sale
2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed in Maverick Noir Frost under a gray-to-white satin wrap went RNM at $79,574. thefleshrocket: "There's probably extra money to be had for a buyer who specifically wants the maverick noir frost paint, but not with it hidden under a wrap." Brandon70: "its a sin to cover up MNF... if you wanted to protect it just PPF the whole thing!" PPF, by contrast, is neutral-to-positive — 7k-Mile 2022 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed had $7k of XPEL stealth film and made $91,500.
Special/anniversary editions (120th, Le Monstre) premium on manuals only; discount versus MSRP across the board 120th manuals $97,500-$111,000; 120th automatics $96,500-$100,200 against $142-143k stickers
Slicktop (no UltraView sunroof) and rare colours among enthusiasts premium unclear — not isolable in this sample
Icecreammatt on 5k-Mile 2022 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed (Shadow Metallic, $87,000): "With the two most important options, A slick top and a stick!" Techdude99 on the wrapped 2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed: "No sunroof and manual. MNF looks amazing... This is a collector's car." Yet the slicktop cars in this set ($87,000, $88,500 for 1,500-Mile 2022 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed) did not obviously outrun sunroofed comps. Treat the slicktop premium as thread folklore until more data exists. On colour, the only statistically usable split is Black Raven $96,500 (n=5) vs Summit White $89,500 (n=5); Electric Blue was called "polarizing, more so in person" by a local viewer.
Mileage against sold price across the 32 deep-analysed cars.
Median by transmission
Spec
Median
Cars
Manual
$91,000
26
Automatic
$89,500
6
Median by exterior colour
Colour
Median
Cars
Black Raven
$96,500
5
Summit White
$89,500
5
Cuts with fewer than 5 cars are left out of the two tables above:
Deep Space Metallic (exterior colour, 1 car), Satin Steel Metallic (exterior colour, 1 car), Shadow Metallic (exterior colour, 3 cars), Wave Metallic (exterior colour, 3 cars), Argent Silver Metallic (exterior colour, 2 cars), Rift Metallic (exterior colour, 3 cars), Radiant Red Tintcoat (exterior colour, 2 cars), Dark Emerald Frost Matte (exterior colour, 1 car), and 4 more. A median of two or three cars is not an
estimate of anything, and sorted beside a real one it reads as a price difference that the record does
not actually support.
Known issues
minorSerial Data Gateway Module battery drain — GM customer satisfaction program N242435630 (OTA updates can flatten the battery)
raised or shown on Carfax in at least 5 of the 40 cars reviewed
Check: Pull the Carfax/GM VIN lookup for open field action N242435630 (released 09/18/2024, expires 10/31/2026) and get a dealer print-out showing the module was reprogrammed. If unperformed and the car has sat, test the battery and expect to replace it.
moderateCars delivered from the factory out of alignment, and Precision Package toe links left uninstalled by dealers
raised on 2 of 40, both by owner-commenters, on the newest cars
AZSkye on 2026 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed: "Nice to see it has been aligned as many of these came from the factory not aligned properly." On the other 2026 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed, ezndo wrote: "the Precision Package toe links are not installed but can be found in their boxes in the trunk as pictured here. After installation, an alignment should be performed. This is all part of the PDI that should be completed before the new owner takes possession." The seller confirmed he deliberately left the car "non dealer prepped."
Check: Ask for a four-wheel alignment printout. On a Precision Package car, physically confirm the toe links are fitted to the car and not sitting in a box in the trunk, and that an alignment followed.
Check: Get the car on a lift or ask for underside photos of the splitter and rocker extensions. On CF1 cars the splitter is carbon, not plastic — replacement is expensive, and scrapes through the weave are not buffable.
moderateCatalytic converter failures under warranty
raised on 1 of 40, but both cats on the same car by 21k miles
21k-Mile 2022 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed showed both catalytic converters replaced under warranty (one May 2025) plus an ECM reprogram. Commenter tbork: "Catalytic converter replaced, Exhaust manifold replaced, Engine/powertrain computer/module reprogrammed. It shows the cats being replaced twice? why" The seller said only the cats were done, not the manifold — a discrepancy that was never documented. The car went unsold at $74,000.
Check: Carfax/dealer history for cat or exhaust manifold replacement; scan for stored emissions codes; confirm whether the 8yr/80k emissions warranty is intact for the next owner.
On 2026 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed, commenter PVcarfan asked "any evidence that the oil pan has begun to leak again?" — the wording implies known history in the owner community. The seller answered that he had seen no active leak but could not supply undercarriage photographs before the auction closed. Treat this as a single unverified thread claim, but it is cheap to check.
Check: Undercarriage inspection of the oil pan and rear main area on a lift; ask the selling dealer for any warranty claim on the pan or its sealant.
minorCarbon-fibre interior trim: squeaking seatbacks and cracking console pieces
raised on 2 of 40
On 1,500-Mile 2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed, rjwad explained the "carbon fiber seat back delete" on the window sticker: "The CF seatback delete saves $2,900 from the $8K option... Some delete the seatback because they complain about squeaking." On the 9,600-mile 2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed the seller disclosed "my daughter climbed into the front seat from the back and now there is a small crack on the carbon fiber near the shifter"; RealtorChrisKC priced the replacement at $466.07.
Check: Press and listen around the carbon seatbacks; inspect the console piece around the shifter for cracks. Parts are dealer-priced but available.
Check: Photograph the inner barrels of all four wheels; run a paint meter across the front fascia and fenders; if Carfax shows a pre-delivery bumper or impact-bar repair, demand the repair order — do not accept a verbal 'transport damage' explanation.
minorOption content missing versus the window sticker (CF1 wheel-well deflectors, PDR)
raised on 2 of 40 — and in both cases the seller did not know until a commenter noticed
On 5k-Mile 2022 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed, Bcpanis asked "Any idea why this car is missing the carbon front wheel well deflectors? I thought these were part of the CF1 package" — the seller had not noticed, found they were absent at original delivery, and committed to sourcing parts at roughly $750 each. On 867-Mile 2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 120th Anniversary Edition 6-Speed, commenters 10056753c and IXFE proved the advertised Performance Data Recorder was absent; BaT removed it from the listing.
Check: Line-by-line reconciliation of the window sticker against the physical car: wheel-well deflectors behind the front wheels, the PDR memory-stick slot in the console, rear camera mirror, park assist sensors.
moderateFactory warranty transfer ambiguity on quick flips and Canadian-market cars
raised on 3 of 40, never definitively resolved by any seller
8k-Mile 2024 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed: commenters 1saville, HealeyB and Slimhelen pressed on whether warranty transferred given the car left Canada in under six months; the seller gave contradictory answers and Zenk advised "calling the dealer to verify." On 2024 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed (2,400 miles, sold $89,500), SLW4491 wrote "it would be very helpful to know for certain that the 4 year, 50,000 mile warranty is, in fact, transferable" — no definitive answer came. On 46-Mile 2025 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing Le Monstre Edition the seller confirmed glass and paint warranty were voided: "Glass and Paint yes."
Check: Call a Cadillac dealer with the VIN before bidding and confirm in-service date, remaining B2B/powertrain coverage and that coverage follows the car to a second US owner. For Canadian cars, confirm the car was out of Canada long enough and that GM has recorded the transfer.
moderateUndercarriage corrosion on winter-region cars, even ultra-low-mileage ones
raised on 1 of 40 — but it cost that car its sale
On 46-Mile 2025 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing Le Monstre Edition, deepsee71 posted "the corrosion on all the aluminum stuff is from being in the winter salt. look at all the pics it's filthy, rusted and corroded for 47 miles... I was a bidder till I saw the underneath" — an active bidder walked. trizzuth flagged the rusted H-pipe and discoloured bolts in photos 296-312. The seller conceded the car had been in Michigan in November-December. Reserve was not met at $134,000. Separately, a benign lookalike: black streaks under the rear muffler are factory condensation drain holes, confirmed by owners on 7k-Mile 2022 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed and 1,900-Mile 2022 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed — do not pay a discount for those.
Check: Photographs of the H-pipe, subframe fasteners and suspension links. Distinguish weld scale and light surface oxidation from salt-driven corrosion; check the Carfax for Michigan/Ontario/northeast registration.
minorRotor warping and brake-light seal condensation (reported on the CT4-V Blackwing, unconfirmed on CT5)
raised on 1 of 40, by a CT4 owner
On 4,800-Mile 2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed, Ferrarifanclif82 wrote "Only 2 gripes I have about mine is the seals on the brakelights... Also, my brake rotors warped by 20K miles..I think probably from setting the parking brake after highway driving." That is a CT4-V Blackwing, and AZSkye noted the CT5 uses different tail-lights, so weight this lightly. Carbon-ceramic cars are effectively immune — AZSkye rates the ceramics good for "up to 100K miles unless you track it."
Check: If the car has iron rotors, check for pedal pulsation at speed and measure runout; ask whether the owner habitually set the parking brake after hard driving. Inspect tail-light lenses for moisture.
Check: Count Carfax title events, not the seller's owner count. Ask each prior owner's holding period and why they sold. Repetitive short-interval service entries on a sub-5,000-mile car deserve a direct question about track use.
Reconcile the window sticker against the physical car, item by item: CF1 front splitter, grille header, rocker extensions and the two carbon wheel-well deflectors; CF2 rear spoiler and diffuser; the PDR memory-stick slot; rear camera mirror; front/rear park assist (option code 00Z means credited-out and possibly retrofitted later).
Confirm open GM field action N242435630 (Serial Data Gateway Module / battery drain) has been performed, and ask for the dealer invoice — not just the seller's word.
Get a four-wheel alignment printout. If it is a Precision Package car, verify the toe links are installed on the car and the alignment post-dates that install.
Put it on a lift. Photograph the oil pan, the H-pipe, subframe fasteners, the underside of the front splitter and the inner wheel barrels. Distinguish benign muffler drain-hole soot from actual salt corrosion.
Paint-meter the front fascia, hood and fenders. Several delivery-mile cars in this set had pre-delivery bumper or impact-bar repairs that Carfax reported only as a service line.
On any car with under 5,000 miles that is more than two years old, ask where it was stored and whether the battery was on a tender; check tyre date codes against claimed replacements and inspect for flat-spotting on Pilot Sport 4S/Cup2 rubber.
On iron-rotor cars, drive it above 70 mph and brake hard from speed — look for pulsation; on ceramic cars, check for chipped or cracked rotor edges and confirm caliper colour matches the sticker.
Call a Cadillac dealer with the VIN before bidding: in-service date, remaining B2B (4yr/50k) and powertrain (6yr/70k) coverage, and confirm coverage transfers to you. Do this specifically on Canadian-market cars and on cars being flipped within 12 months of delivery.
Check the title for a lien — this model's BaT record is littered with them, including one post-sale dispute. Ask for a lien-release letter or payoff confirmation in writing before you wire funds.
Test every drive mode and the MagneRide, cycle the rev-match and no-lift-shift, and check the clutch take-up. Manual cars have no AFM or stop/start — confirm you are actually buying the Tremec car and not an auto misdescribed in the title.
Inspect carbon interior trim around the shifter and the carbon seatbacks for cracks and squeaks; note whether the sticker shows the $2,900 carbon seatback delete.
If the car is wrapped, budget for removal and inspect underneath before bidding — a wrap hides paint and, per this record, actively suppresses the price.
Ask the seller
Can you send the full window sticker and confirm CF1 and CF2 content is physically present, including the carbon wheel-well deflectors?
Has field action N242435630 been completed, and can you email the dealer repair order showing it?
Do you have a recent alignment printout? Were the Precision Package toe links installed by the dealer, and when?
Has the oil pan, rear main or any exhaust component (cats, manifold) ever been serviced or replaced under warranty? Can I see the claim history from the dealer?
Has this car ever seen a track day, autocross or a driving school with lapping — and are the multiple short-interval service entries on the Carfax track-related?
What is the winter storage story: garaged, battery tender, any salt-road exposure or northern registration?
Is there a lien? Who holds it, what is the payoff, and will you provide a lien release before transport?
Was this car ever wrapped or resprayed, and can I have paint-meter readings on the front clip, hood and fenders?
Was the front bumper, impact bar or any panel repaired before you took delivery? If the dealer did transport-damage work, can you get the repair order released?
Have you confirmed with Cadillac that the balance of factory warranty transfers to me — specifically if you have owned it under 12 months, or if the car was originally Canadian?
How many prior owners appear on the Carfax as title events (not your count), and why did each sell?
For 2025-26 cars: what did you actually pay, and what is your reserve? These have failed reserve at $95k, $117k and $135k on BaT — I want to know we are not in that territory.
Walk away when
Sellers anchored to MSRP or build cost. Every reserve failure in this set traces to it: $135,000 asked against $144,390 sticker, $117,000 against $139,500, $95,000 against $107,960, and a 2024 Canadian car that stalled at $75,777 when "Seller paid $77k USD for this new. I'm out" (evoshift). MSRP is irrelevant to this market now.
Liens disclosed late or not at all. On 11-Mile 2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing 6-Speed the buyer discovered an active Vermont lien after the hammer despite the listing claiming a clean title, and threatened to walk. Treat any lien as unresolved until you see the release.
Base-spec automatics priced like optioned manuals. 1,200-Mile 2023 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing — described by thefleshrocket as "about as close to a stripper model 5BW as you could get" — failed at $76,500 with only 1,200 miles. No amount of low mileage rescues a no-option car.
Full vinyl wraps over desirable factory paint, and aftermarket hood stripes laid over PPF. Both examples in this set failed to sell.
Dealer or enthusiast-flipper sellers with immediate turnover: a car bought CPO and relisted inside 30 days, a 2026 whose seller said "gotta keep my money working to buy more cool inventory," and a 2024 flipped after one year and 15,000 miles whose owner refused a requested paint-meter reading. Ask harder in these threads, not less.
Delivery-mile cars with scraped splitters, scuffed inner rims or replaced impact bars — the transport chain on these did real damage and sellers often 'don't recall' it.
Undercarriage photos withheld or unavailable before close. It happened on the 2026 with the oil-pan question, and on the Le Monstre the photos that did exist cost the seller his highest bidder.
Consensus valuations from the same recurring commenters. badcad, AZSkye and Zenk appear across dozens of threads and are consistently 15-25% above where cars actually hammer — "I'm thinking 110k" preceded an $86,000 sale. Enthusiasm in the thread is not a comp.
For 2026 cars specifically: there is no clearing price in this data — three offered, three unsold at $95,000, $117,000 and $135,000. Anchor an offer on a comparable 2024-25 result plus a modest allowance for warranty, not on the sticker.
The highest sold price in the last two years and roughly 41% above the trailing-12-month median of $90,000. One owner, 2,300 miles, manual, Precision Package with carbon-ceramics, and a two-bidder duel (Paul765lt vs Mo305) from a $20,000 open. badcad had called it at "worth 120k" — it beat that. Proof that a genuinely fresh, correctly optioned facelift manual can still print a big number even in a falling market.
Sold roughly $13k over its $111,005 original MSRP with no CF1/CF2. Three bidders ran it up; Jmassey03 called it directly: "100% overpaid. By no means is this the current market... This car wasn't worth more than $95k with the BaT fee." A late-bidding artefact, not a comp.
Effectively a new car sold at no reserve — CF1/CF2, carbon-ceramics, Electric Blue, 3 miles, still under factory protective film — yet it went $10,990 under its $128,990 sticker, prompting bobshm's "the seller is happy? Brand new, never driven. What was the point?" Sets the practical ceiling for delivery-mile pre-facelift cars.
The weakest result of any sub-10,000-mile car in the set: one owner, 6,000 miles, CF1 added, full XPEL, ceramic coat, transferable 8yr/80k warranty — but an automatic, and carrying a ~$35k lien. JakeTheSnake115: "This is wildly cheaper than I thought it would go." The automatic discount in its purest form.
Manual, CF1, carbon-ceramics, PDR, full XPEL and ceramic coating on a $122,490 build with 15,000 miles — sold for $86,000. badcad opened the thread at "I'm thinking 110k"; AZSkye closed it with "Wow. $86K!!!??? A fantastic deal for the buyer." The clearest evidence that 15k miles and 2024 model year now cost you more than the option list returns.
2,600 miles, rare Dark Emerald Frost (~104 built for 2022), Natural Tan with carbon seatbacks, $104,930 MSRP — but automatic. Zenk, an owner, posted "This car is worth at least $20k more than the current bid." It sold at $85,000 anyway. Rare colour plus rare interior did not offset two pedals.
#70 of 101 worldwide, 46 miles, and still unsold at $134,000. An automatic-only special edition with a voided glass and paint warranty and visible undercarriage corrosion that drove bidder deepsee71 out. tcolum's warning — "the anniversary cars have shown steep decline (I own one)" — is the lesson: limited-edition badging is not the value driver on this model.
Maverick Noir Frost, manual, slicktop, 19,000 miles — a spec Techdude99 called "a collector's car" — yet RNM at $79,574 because the original paint was buried under an 18-month-old satin vinyl wrap with peeling edges. thefleshrocket: "There's probably extra money to be had for a buyer who specifically wants the maverick noir frost paint, but not with it hidden under a wrap."
Verdict
Buy the spec sheet, not the story. The right car is a pre-facelift (2022-24) six-speed with CF1/CF2, the upgraded interior, ideally carbon-ceramics, under 5,000 miles and a single owner — and at today's money that is $90,000-$102,000, roughly 20-25% off what it stickered for. If you intend to drive it, a 10,000-20,000-mile manual at $80,000-$88,000 is the value play in this entire dataset and the mechanicals appear to be holding up: badcad, who has tracked his seven times, reports it "flawless," and the only recurring hard failures in 40 threads are catalytic converters on one high-mile car and a single oil-pan mention. What you should not do is pay anniversary-edition or 2026 money. Median prices have fallen every year since 2022 ($125,068 to $87,750), the trailing year is down 6.9%, and 30% of consignments fail to sell — almost always because the seller is pricing off a window sticker. Let them fail, then buy the relisting.
Several planks here are thin and should be discounted accordingly. The transmission comparison rests on just six automatics against 26 manuals — the $1,500 median gap is meaningless, and my stronger claim about the automatic discount is built on thread sentiment plus two reserve failures, not on statistics. Colour analysis is effectively unusable: only Black Raven (n=5) and Summit White (n=5) clear the threshold, and twelve other colours have one to three cars each, so do not read a premium into Maverick Noir Frost, Radiant Red or Dark Emerald Frost however much commenters praise them. The early-year medians are tiny samples (four cars in 2022, eight in 2023), so the peak-to-trough decline is directionally sound but imprecise. Option content is not captured in the computed statistics at all — my CF1/CF2 premium is inferred by comparing individual listings, and those cars differ in mileage, year and colour simultaneously, so the $10-20k figure is an estimate rather than a measurement. 2026 model-year pricing is genuinely unknown: three offered, none sold. Finally, almost every technical claim about failure points comes from BaT comment threads. A handful of prolific commenters (badcad, AZSkye, Zenk, thefleshrocket, manofmanuals) appear across many of these listings; they are credible owners, but they are strangers with opinions, they consistently over-forecast hammer prices, and claims like the oil-pan leak, the factory misalignment and the CT4 rotor warping each rest on a single post with no documentation attached.
Bidding patterns
These are patterns, not findings. A public auction
record cannot show intent, and everything below has ordinary explanations — specialists and
dealers bid on many cars of one model, enthusiasts run up cars they end up losing, and new
accounts are usually just new. Read them as places to look closely, not as accusations.
Screened 40 bid ladders
· 13 with something to note · 0 repeat-bidder patterns · thresholds set against this model's own auctions (typical closing window is 46% low-history bidders)
· usernames masked for public viewing
22 bids from 8 accounts ·
sold $88,500 ·
winner W••••2 · underbidder C••••••3
watchUnderbidder placed much of the ladder — Curtischevrolet53 placed 8 of 22 bids (36%) and did not win. Enthusiastic losing bidders are common; a very high share is still worth reading the thread for.
12 bids from 3 accounts ·
no sale, bid to $117,000 ·
winner g••••••9 · underbidder c••••••t
watchUnderbidder placed much of the ladder — cswiggett placed 4 of 12 bids (33%) and did not win. Enthusiastic losing bidders are common; a very high share is still worth reading the thread for.
noticePrice set by two accounts trading bids — 70% of the ladder is the same two accounts alternating. This is what a genuine duel looks like too — it only matters alongside another signal.
23 bids from 8 accounts ·
no sale, bid to $134,000 ·
winner G••••••e · underbidder R••••••D
watchUnderbidder placed much of the ladder — RARE-FIND placed 8 of 23 bids (35%) and did not win. Enthusiastic losing bidders are common; a very high share is still worth reading the thread for.
21 bids from 7 accounts ·
sold $94,000 ·
winner J••••••o · underbidder C••••••s
noticePrice set by two accounts trading bids — 68% of the ladder is the same two accounts alternating. This is what a genuine duel looks like too — it only matters alongside another signal.
7 bids from 4 accounts ·
sold $90,000 ·
winner J••••••0 · underbidder n••••••o
watchUnderbidder placed much of the ladder — newcarpro placed 3 of 7 bids (43%) and did not win. Enthusiastic losing bidders are common; a very high share is still worth reading the thread for.
noticePrice set by two accounts trading bids — 60% of the ladder is the same two accounts alternating. This is what a genuine duel looks like too — it only matters alongside another signal.
16 bids from 10 accounts ·
sold $93,000 ·
winner A••••••l · underbidder r••••o
watchClosing bids came almost entirely from accounts with no posting history — 7 of 8 bids in the final 15 minutes (88%) came from accounts with under 25 lifetime likes (AlanBell, rolnlo). The typical auction for this model runs 46%, so this one is an outlier. Note the measure is weak — likes come from commenting, so a long-time bidder who never posts also scores zero.
29 bids from 16 accounts ·
sold $97,500 ·
winner g••••••g · underbidder F••••••o
watchClosing bids came almost entirely from accounts with no posting history — 11 of 13 bids in the final 15 minutes (85%) came from accounts with under 25 lifetime likes (Joeblackjack, Robert148, cwkoch, garretwing). The typical auction for this model runs 46%, so this one is an outlier. Note the measure is weak — likes come from commenting, so a long-time bidder who never posts also scores zero.
26 bids from 14 accounts ·
sold $85,668 ·
winner R••••••8 · underbidder A••••••K
watchClosing bids came almost entirely from accounts with no posting history — 12 of 12 bids in the final 15 minutes (100%) came from accounts with under 25 lifetime likes (AnonUserHrMWK, Robert148). The typical auction for this model runs 46%, so this one is an outlier. Note the measure is weak — likes come from commenting, so a long-time bidder who never posts also scores zero.
Ultra-low-mileage factory-fresh manual Cadillac sedan with superb credentials and minor cosmetic blemish, sold in a competitive bidding war to an enthusiast at $127,305, representing strong market validation for modern American performance manuals.
Duplicate title on record (original misplaced) · Paint blemish on hood requiring explanation
Clean, low-mileage 2023 CT5-V Blackwing with full service history and no structural issues commanded $81,500 despite lacking optional carbon-fiber exterior packages and automatic-only transmission, reflecting strong collector demand for modern American performance sedans.
Immaculate first-owner manual Blackwing with only 1,500 miles and full documentation, but reserve unmet at $90,500 suggests seller priced above market appetite for museum-piece rather than driven performance sedan.
A well-maintained, low-mileage manual Blackwing with impeccable mechanicals and original paint that was wrapped for protection three weeks after purchase, causing the car to miss reserve despite strong fundamentals and suggesting the owner's protective overreach may have cost six figures in resale value.
Lien on vehicle requires seller's lender payoff before title transfer · Wrap obscures original Maverick Noir Frost paint, which commenters suggest would have been more attractive to buyers and generated higher interest
A pristine, low-mileage, well-optioned manual Cadillac super-sedan with strong collector appeal, though the seller's initial misrepresentation of 'collector series' status warrants minor scrutiny.
seller initially misrepresented car as 'collector series' limited edition when it is regular production; BaT corrected listing but this indicates either seller confusion or intentional mischaracterization
Immaculate, comprehensively protected 1,400-mile manual-transmission supercharged Cadillac sedan from the final production year fell $22.5k short of MSRP at auction, likely due to market saturation concerns and anticipated next-gen Blackwing announcement rather than any mechanical or condition defect.
Reserve not met at auction · Auction underperformance: high bid of $117k well below $139.5k MSRP despite one owner, 1,400 miles, Precision Package, Carbon Fiber 1&2, and extensive aftermarket protection · Bidding stalled after 7/25/2026 with no additional bids for final 4 days, unusual for high-value collector car
A pristine, two-owner, 4,900-mile 2024 CT5-V Blackwing manual with desired bronze package and carbon-ceramic brakes, last of the favored generation with minor cosmetic chips, sold fairly at $93.5k (18% off MSRP) to a bidder who beat strong competition and acquired a car that multiple owners confirm punches above its segment weight class.
Ohio title noted as replacement (non-standard) · Substantial maintenance records for 4,900-mile, 2-year-old car—original owner history and care level not explicitly detailed
A genuinely low-mileage final-generation manual performance sedan with proper break-in and comprehensive options, but a small dent and prior oil-pan service history that the seller couldn't fully explain, combined with unmet reserve, suggest the market was right to be cautious about the asking price.
oil pan leak history mentioned · oil pan leak mentioned in comment thread as 'again,' suggesting prior service/issue not detailed in listing · seller unable to provide undercarriage photos of oil pan/suspension before auction close despite request
A pristine but compromised ultra-rare special edition hampered by automatic transmission, weather-damaged undercarriage, voided warranty, and market skepticism about collector appreciation—the reserve not being met at $134k signals genuine uncertainty about its long-term value despite its 101-unit scarcity.
Undercarriage corrosion and rust visible · Glass and paint warranty voided · Car previously listed on Facebook Marketplace marked as sold before being moved to BaT; seller attributed to salesman error but raises questions about listing management · Reserve not met at $134,000 hammer price despite initial asking expectation and seller enthusiasm
Exceptionally low-mileage, well-optioned first-owner Cadillac with comprehensive protective work and transferable warranty, sold at a surprisingly modest price for its specification and rarity.
Lien on vehicle at time of sale · Future-dated service record (April 2026 oil change mentioned in May 2026 listing suggests data entry error) · Lien on title required seller payoff (resolved by seller commitment)
A meticulously maintained, exceptionally rare six-speed manual Shadow Metallic CT5-V Blackwing with comprehensive track-focused options, clean history, and professional cosmetic prep, tempered only by minor questions about transport damage documentation and a missing carbon-fiber deflector that the seller has committed to sourcing, sold at fair market value after a 24-month hold that added minimal mileage.
carbon-fiber front wheel deflectors missing · Ownership history complex: four entries on Carfax (original owner, brief Hennessy Porsche trade, repurchase by original owner, Ed Morse Cadillac, then BaT seller #2, then current seller), though seller claims only three true owners—raises questions about title clarity · front bumper impact bar replacement at delivery with dealer unable/unwilling to provide repair documentation or photos, only partially explained as transport damage
A nearly-new, single-owner, ultra-low-mileage manual CT5-V Blackwing with full provenance and two cosmetic dings (garage scrape + child-induced carbon fiber crack) that sold at a steep discount to comparable examples, driven by aggressive bidding dynamic among collectors recognizing rarity and manual-transmission desirability in a production-run sunset model.
multiple speed citations (100mph+) within last 2 years suggesting aggressive use despite low mileage · no winter tires fitted; Michelin Pilot Sport unsuitable for cold/snow; car hibernates in winter per commenter badcad
A meticulously preserved, factory-optioned manual Blackwing with near-zero real-world use that commanded above-MSRP money in a brisk bidding war, driven partly by extreme rarity of this specific color/interior/spec combination and partly by market momentum for manual V8 Cadillacs.
A well-specced 2026 CT5-V Blackwing with 859 miles and exemplary options that failed to clear its reserve, likely because the dealer-seller overestimated value after drive-testing it personally and the incomplete toe-link installation signaled to bidders that minimal dealer prep was performed.
seller is a dealer flipping personal vehicle; stated 'I buy them all for the experience' and 'gotta keep my money working to buy more cool inventory'; reserve not met at $135k despite MSRP of $144,390, suggesting overpriced or specification not as desirable as seller believed · precision package toe links left uninstalled despite being part of dealer prep; new owner must complete this work and alignment
Nearly new, comprehensively optioned manual Blackwing with all desirable performance and aesthetic packages, sold at 28% off MSRP to an enthusiast planning track duty—a straightforward, low-mileage execution with no disclosed issues or red flags.
A pristine, comprehensively optioned 2023 CT5-V Blackwing with the scarce manual transmission and carbon-fiber packages in excellent condition at 4,800 miles, though repetitive service entries warrant verification that it was not abused on track despite seller's claim of primarily street use.
Repetitive services logged despite very low mileage (4,800 miles) and recent delivery—raises question of track use or dealer servicing patterns that seller did not clarify
A meticulously preserved ultra-low-mileage American supercar that suffered only minor shipping damage, corrected a PDR disclosure error when challenged, and sold smartly at a 24% discount to dealer MSRP—a legitimate collector's piece for the manual-transmission faithful.
Discrepancy between original shipping window sticker (incomplete) and Carfax window sticker (full pricing information); seller stated original sticker does not have car info and was for 'shipping purposes only' · Minor damage (front splitter scuff) occurred during shipping but seller did not proactively disclose this
Well-spec'd, low-mileage, one-owner manual Blackwing with clean history that narrowly missed reserve at auction but sold off-platform for $90k—a fair price reflecting manual transmission and production scarcity despite modest real-world mileage accumulation.
initial lack of transparency about out-of-state purchase history before clarification
A mechanically sound, low-mileage factory Blackwing limited by base-spec automatic transmission and stripped options that failed to clear reserve, suggesting market correction downward from dealer expectations on this entry-level variant.
Reserve not met · Reserve not met suggests overpricing relative to market appetite for automatic, base-spec Blackwing · Tire metadata inconsistency between Carfax record and physical inspection raises transparency question
Exceptionally clean, low-mileage manual Blackwing with full PPF protection and no track history, but reserve failure signals market skepticism about pricing in a softening CT5-V segment despite strong peer enthusiasm.
lien on vehicle noted—lender payoff required before title transfer · PPF installed by previous owner with no invoice provided; timing and condition unclear
A meticulously preserved, high-spec 2024 CT5-V Blackwing with rare carbon ceramics and manual trans sold below comparable recent market examples, likely reflecting either seller's prioritization of quick exit over maximum price or genuine market softening for low-mileage new Cadillacs being flipped by speculators.
seller is flipping a car acquired for personal use after only one year and 15k miles; motivation stated as need to focus on another business project rather than natural ownership conclusion · paint meter readings were not provided despite buyer (Nacoocheejohn) requesting them; seller dismissed the request as unnecessary for a 1-year-old car, though commenter correctly noted accidents can occur and be paid out-of-pocket to avoid Carfax reporting
A clean, single-owner garage queen with rare color/manual combo and factory warranty remaining, but early dual catalytic converter replacements and service record discrepancies warrant pre-purchase inspection despite seller's warranty narrative.
catalytic converter failures on both sides within first 3 years/21k miles suggests potential underlying emissions or engine issue, despite seller's warranty explanation · discrepancy between Carfax listing (exhaust manifold) and seller's account of service performed
A delivery-mileage 120th Anniversary manual Blackwing with full options and clean history that sold $18.5K below MSRP due to missing COA and expired first-owner benefits, landing below some initial dealer enthusiasm but above the most recent automatic example to clear the block.
Certificate of Authenticity and Spring Mountain driving school benefits not included · Certificate of Authenticity missing or location unknown at time of auction · Spring Mountain V-Performance Academy trip eligibility expired (only valid for first owner, one year window)
A pristine, comprehensively optioned 2022 CT5-V Blackwing in rare matte paint with 7k miles, sold for $91.5k to an informed buyer who recognized strong value despite approaching 3-year-old inventory, with full transparency from a conscientious original owner and no material defects beyond cosmetic wear.
Lien on vehicle at time of listing (seller addressed by paying off balance mid-auction after buyer concern raised)
A well-sorted, low-mileage manual performance sedan that held its value impressively, but the three ownership changes in three years and recent acquisition/quick flip raise questions about whether this is a treated collectible or a circulation vehicle.
Multiple owners in 3 years · 3 owners in approximately 3 years since 2021 delivery · Seller acquired car in 2024 and is already selling at 23k miles after only ~1 year of ownership
A comprehensively optioned, garage-kept 2023 Cadillac manual V8 with full PPF that failed to meet its seller's inflated reserve but found a buyer at a reasonable post-auction discount after the market firmly rejected the asking price.
Lien on vehicle requires lender payoff before title transfer · Unusually low mileage (65 miles) on 2023 model year vehicle—no explanation provided for storage duration
Exceptionally well-documented, low-mileage first-owner 2022 CT5-V Blackwing with the increasingly rare manual transmission, no modifications beyond tint, clean history, and strong market validation through competitive late-stage bidding—sold at $85,668 representing robust value retention.
A pristine, barely-broken-in manual CT5-V Blackwing purchased by a compassionate CEO to help the family of his late executive—sold without fanfare at 12% off sticker to a buyer who recognized its track-capable versatility and value.
A genuinely low-mileage, collector-owned manual Blackwing in solid spec with full PPF and functioning retrofit sensors that sold well above market comps due to final-minutes bidding intensity, though independent commenters questioned whether the premium was justified versus comparable examples and new-car pricing.
Initial documentation confusion when seller posted wrong build sheet and MSRP figure · Parking sensors noted as 'later retrofit' on build sheet rather than factory-original
A pristine, one-owner 120th Anniversary special edition (limited to 120 units) with full carbon fiber and extended warranty coverage sold at a steep $46k loss to original MSRP, suggesting soft market demand for high-priced four-door performance sedans despite strong enthusiast sentiment.
Lien on vehicle requires seller's lender payoff before title transfer · Transferability of extended warranty and maintenance plans not confirmed by seller; AZSkye notes GMPP transfers for $50 but other plans unclear
A low-mileage, well-optioned 2024 CT5-V Blackwing 6MT Canadian import with enthusiast credibility but muddied warranty transfer status to the second US owner that buyers should independently verify with Cadillac before closing.
warranty transfer status unclear · Canadian import with unclear warranty transfer status to second owner in US · Car left Canada in under six months (per Carfax per Slimhelen's observation), triggering warranty ambiguity per seller's own stated rules
Garage-kept, single-owner, 1,900-mile 2022 CT5-V Blackwing with full factory warranty, no history or issues, sold to a repeat Blackwing buyer at 12% depreciation—a clean, well-documented example in a market where manual V-series Cadillacs command stable value.
Ultra-low-mileage, garage-kept, corporate-liaison-secured CF1/CF2 6-speed manual Blackwing with flawless service history and clean provenance sold above depreciation curve, but GM Financial lien title-transfer terms require buyer verification before close.
Lien held by GM Financial; title transfer process unclear · Lienholder is GM Financial; buyer must verify title transfer process directly with GM Financial, as seller disclaims responsibility for changes in procedure · Seller's early oil change at 500 miles deviates from manufacturer break-in specification; while seller claims it was to remove 'residual contamination,' this is non-standard and could mask unknown issues
Extraordinarily rare, low-mileage manual Cadillac V8 with dream specification sold under MSRP, but marred by post-sale discovery of undisclosed title lien and test-drive mileage inflation that should have raised red flags pre-listing.
Title lien not disclosed pre-sale · Serial Data Gateway Module field action · Title lien not disclosed at auction close despite listing claim of 'clean Vermont title' · Lien release not provided to buyer pre-transaction; seller claimed payoff 'takes time'
A well-maintained, low-mileage 2022 CT5-V Blackwing with the prized 6-speed manual failed to clear its reserve at $79k, likely because buyers view low-option examples as commodity inventory rather than collectible, and the polarizing Electric Blue color may have deterred mainstream performance-car bidders.
car is 3 years old with only 2,100 miles (~700 miles/year), suggesting very limited use or potential storage issues · reserve not met at $79,000 final bid despite being well below MSRP
A pristine, fully-optioned final-generation manual Cadillac performance sedan that sold $11k under MSRP with an open Field Action pending, suggesting the dealer had motivated reasons to liquidate despite what appears to be a collectible configuration.
Lien status initially unclear; seller eventually clarified lien already paid off but bank processing release · Car sold $10,990 under original $128,990 MSRP for a brand new delivery-condition vehicle with no reserve—unclear motivation for dealer to liquidate immediately
A low-mileage 2024 Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing in rare six-speed manual with highly desirable carbon-fiber packages, offered by a respected dealer seller, sold below expected market for $89,500 despite an unresolved warranty-transferability question that the seller declined to clarify.
Warranty transferability uncertain: car sold within 12 months of original delivery (8/24/2023); seller stated Cadillac had no issues with warranty transfer but could not guarantee manufacturer enforcement. Buyers SLW4491 and carmecrazy pressed for clarification multiple times and did not receive definitive answer
Pristine, spec'd 2024 manual Blackwing with ultra-low mileage and rare Coastal Blue finish failed to meet reserve, despite strong mechanical appeal and condition, likely due to cross-border import friction and final bid pricing near original retail cost in a soft market.
car is located in Canada; cross-border import to US involves customs, regulatory compliance verification, and buyer responsibility for logistics and fees · reserve not met at final bid of USD $75,777; seller's cost was approximately USD $77,000 new, raising questions about realistic valuation
A comprehensively optioned, ultra-low-mileage 120th Anniversary special edition with the only real collector caveat—automatic transmission—sold to a committed buyer at fair market for its class and specification.
Serial Data Gateway Module recall · Automatic transmission in a high-performance collector car may limit future resale to purist buyers · Radar detectors mounted to steering column and rearview mirror suggest heavy traffic enforcement avoidance focus
A pristine, single-owner, garage-kept 2022 CT5-V Blackwing in the rare Dark Emerald Frost with the coveted Natural Tan/Jet Black/carbon-fiber interior package, dealer-serviced at ultra-low mileage, that sold at a substantial discount to current market value in a soft automotive market.
Lien on vehicle requires payoff before title transfer
Compiled by Porsche P.I.
Sign in to appraise a specific car or refresh this case.